Paradise Hotel, June 30: Would You Like a Hot Fudge Sundae or Some Cheesecake?

Next to select a woman is Zack. He can't select Amy because he's been rooming with her this week. He immediately goes for Toni. Hmm, just a few weeks ago he was all hot for Amanda and Kristen. I wonder what's changed. Host Amanda asks him why he picked Toni. Zack believes he and Toni will be really good roommates together. His last roommate was different (a statement which prompts laughter from the guests, and Amy to look embarrassed). Zack wants to slow it down this week, which causes further embarrassment for Amy.

Dave is up next. Host Amanda tells him that he got here last week and selected guest Amanda, which shook things up. Flashback to where he keeps telling Beau that he wasn't going to screw him over, take his girl, or be his rival. Now why would Beau interpret it like that? Host Amanda tells him he can't room with guest Amanda again. With that, he grins and immediately selects Charla. Looks like he might have been the only person anticipating the shake-up this week. If he did, he played out his cards perfectly. His reason for picking Charla was that she knew what it was like to be on the outside. He then goes on to say that as much as everybody made him feel welcome, it's a tough group to crack. However, Charla made the most effort to get to know him. Flashback to earlier in the episode, where Amanda told the masseuse she didn't want to share a bed with Dave, because their feet might touch in the middle of the night.

Host Amanda turns to Scott next, reminding us that he roomed with Melanie the first week and Charla this week. He can't pick Charla, so he's forced to make another selection. In a surprise move, he picks Toni, much to her dismay. It's obvious she doesn't want to be the person to force a man to check out. Zack doesn't look too happy either. Scott tells host Amanda that he and Toni had an instant bond, and the bond has just gotten stronger. He thinks Toni is a wonderful person, and he wants to get to know her better. Host Amanda asks him how he feels about battling it out over Toni. He admits he feels terrible about it, and says it's the biggest nightmare he could possibly imagine.

Time for Alex to pick. He's lived with Kristen for two weeks, but it's time for him to select a new roommate. He does... and it's Toni! She now has three men fighting over her! Her eyes pop out, then informs us that she really wants to throw up. She covers her face up once more. Alex tells us his reason for selecting her was closer to Toni than any of the other women. Yes, there is something about Toni.

Andon is the last to select. Host Amanda tells us that he and the very popular Toni have been living together, but it's now time for him to make a switch. He walks around the girls once, then selects... Amy! Now Amy has two guys that want to live with her. He tells us that he knew he was going to pick Amy, and that he was going to stick to his guns. She's been cool to hang out with and is straight-up fun. It would be a natural progression to room with Amy. He, like Beau, doesn't mention that she puts out easily. Now Amy is all upset.

Host Amanda sighs and tells us that tonight there is just one couple that has formed – Dave and Charla. Dave is the only one who is safe. She tells them to go over to the couch and sit down. The camera then pans over the remaining four women. None of them are happy. Amy and Toni don't want to make decisions, and Kristen and Amanda weren't wanted, period. Still, no matter how distasteful it is, Amy has to select one of the two men who picked her as her new roommate. She tells us that it is a difficult decision, and she loves both of them. She then starts crying and, telling Andon that she's sorry, puts the necklace around Beau's neck, and they become roommates. This sets Toni off crying. Her man is now vulnerable. Amy continues to cry as she and Beau join Dave & Charla on the couch.

Host Amanda then informs us we have a situation they've never had before on Paradise Hotel (er, they’ve only had one elimination so far!). Zack, Alex, and Scott have all selected Toni, and she must select one of them to be her roommate. Toni continues to cry, and finally, through her tears, tells the men she loves them all and doesn't know what to do. She admits she needs some strength, some help, and her friends. With tears in her eyes, she picks Alex. She collapses into his arms and keeps sobbing all the way to the couch.

Zack, Scott, and Andon must now select once again, this time between Kristen and guest Amanda. Zack is up first and selects Amanda. Scott then selects Kristen. So it's up to Andon to make his selection, and let the woman decide which man she prefers. He looks at each of them, then selects Amanda. Kristen and Scott become a couple for the next week. Host Amanda asks her how it feels. Kristen responds that she's glad she didn't have to make any of the decisions tonight. She feels good, but feels bad for everybody else.

So it's come down to this; Amanda has to make her choice between Zack and Andon, knowing the one she doesn't pick will be going home. Guest Amanda tells us she never thought she'd be in this situation. Everybody on the couch looks concerned, particularly Toni. Guest Amanda then tells Zack they've had some talks together, and even enjoys fighting with him. She then tells Andon he has charisma and talent, but doesn't feel they gotten to talk as much as she wanted. That's why she is picking Zack. She kisses Andon goodbye and gives him a hug. Toni goes into a fresh storm of tears. We're treated to a voiceover of Andon telling us that he knew Amanda has feelings for Beau, and that she was going to pick Zack because Beau and Zack are close. Host Amanda then tells Andon he has to leave Paradise forever, as Toni continues to cry up a storm.

OK, let me interrupt this program for a few minutes. Andon, if you knew guest Amanda was going to pick Zack, why the hell did you select her instead of Kristen? In fact, since both Amanda and Kristen were available when you made the last selection in the first round, why didn't you select either of them to be your roommate when you had the chance to get them without competition? Was your ego so big that you figured Amy would select you, or was your sex drive working overtime and you took the chance of elimination just to get into bed with her? No matter what, you threw strategy right out the window and eliminated yourself because if it.

Back at the hotel, we cut back to a crying Toni, who tells us that she's just lost her roommate, one of her best friends, her brother, and it's not fair. She then admits that is the way the game is played. Well now Toni, since you've been on reality TV before, you should have known this was a possibility.